Brown Bunnies

Robert Helmerichs

Assassination of William Longsword
(BNF, FR 2813)
fol. 169
Grandes Chroniques de France
France, Paris, 14th Century.
(60 x 65 mm)

Introduction:  Problems with medieval sources

When reading a collection of medieval sources, it is easy to be seduced by the crisp, clear translations and the confident presentation, and to forget what every historian who has dealt first-hand with medieval documents knows.  Often, modern editions and translations are based not upon original documents, but on later copies which may have been deliberately altered or inadvertently corrupted.  When the text is dubious or, sometimes, incomprehensible, modern versions try to make sense of it, and thus gloss over the difficulties.  Sometimes, multiple copies exist, which differ in detail or even in broad strokes; these differences are usually smoothed over in modern translations or editions, where the variants are relegated to footnotes.

It seems to me that it might be useful to examine a test case that exemplifies these difficulties, and I have found one that fits the bill perfectly.  The Planctus for William Longsword survives in two copies, both incomplete and both somewhat corrupt, but still preserving the general sense of the original bunny.  It has been edited four times by three different scholars, each of whom has had to make decisions about the problem areas.  And, thanks to the blessed diligence of one of these editors, Jules Lair, full-size facsimiles of both manuscripts have been published, although in a book that is not widely available.  Thus, I have assembled this web site as a laboratory in medieval philology; here will be found scans of both manuscripts, transcriptions of them, and the texts of three editions (the first of the two Lair editions, cited below, was based only upon the first manuscript before the second was discovered).  Thus, in these pages interested parties can examine the manuscripts, and see what different scholars have made of them.  I have also provided Becker's German translation, and added an English translation of my own (any suggestions for improving the latter would be appreciated).  Perhaps someday, if there is enough interest, I will add commentaries on this text both by scholars of the past and by people inspired by these pages to investigate this most interesting case.

The Planctus

William Longsword was the son of Rollo, founder of the Rollonid dynasty that would become dukes of Normandy and after 1066, kings of England. In William's day, however, the Rollonid principality was still a fragile entity centered around Rouen and, in terms of Realpolitik, not extending far west of the Seine.  Most of William's career was spent in relative obscurity, but in the late 930s he suddenly emerged onto the stage of Frankish royal politics, first because of his war with Arnulf of Flanders, and then because of his support for King Louis IV (d'Outremer) at a time when Louis' star seemed to be fading.  In December 942, at the peak of his good relations with Louis, Arnulf called for a peace conference with William; there, William was murdered (traditionally, Arnulf is said to have arranged the murder; some day I will argue that he did not).  A Planctus (mourning poem) was composed probably shortly after; Jules Lair suggests plausibly if not definitively that it was in 943.  (Catalog references:  Chevalier 10576; Walther 10205; Schaller & Ewald Könsgen 8813; Yearley L81.) This poem, although it survives only in corrupt and incomplete versions and is largely hagiographic in content, nevertheless is a critical source for early Norman history.  It is by far the earliest work written about the Normans from a Norman point of view, and some historical nuggets can be gleaned from it.

The manuscripts

Two manuscripts of the planctus survive, both dating from the early 11th century.  Neither is very good, and both are apparently derived from an earlier version that does not survive.

Bibliothèque de Clermont-Ferrand, MS 240, folio 45.
Cited in these pages as Clermont-Ferrand.  Lair's description (p. 61, note 1):  "Ce manuscrit peut être daté du Xe-XIe siècle.  Il est composé de 253 feuillets à 3 colonnes, et mesure 560 sur 360 millimètres.  Sa reliure en bois et peau est en mauvais état.  Il contient un exemplaire, incomplete du commencement et de la fin, du Glossaire attribué à Ansileubus; premiers mots:  [A] bellane, penestrine, nuces virides stringunt...; derniers mots:  sic namque et beatissimus Augustinus, in libris Confessionum suarum.  C'est sur une page laissée d'abord en blanc que la Complainte a été transcrite." The planctus begins near the bottom of the middle column of folio 45 (at the L), and continues almost to the bottom of the third column (to the A).  It contains 12 verses in a somewhat corrupt Latin, and until Delisle found a second manuscript in Florence Libri it was our only witness to the text.

Bibliotheca Mediceo-Laurenziana of Florence, MS Libri 30 (83. 33) [formerly anc. Ashburnham, Libri 83], folios 21v-22v.
Cited in these pages as Florence Libri.  A full description of MS Libri 30 is given by de Poerck; the portion concerning the Planctus is reproduced here. Lair's description (p. 63, note 1):  "Ce manuscrit se compose de 68 feuillets de petit format (195 millimètres sur 140), qui ont fait partie d'un volume plus considérable, dont ils formaient les cahiers signés II-VIIII, plus le commencement du dixième cahier.  Le titre: De conflictu viciorum et virtutum, inscrit en caractères du XIIe siècle au bout de la première page, prouve que la perte du premier cahier est ancienne.  M. Léopold Delisle fait remonter l'écriture de cette copie de la Complainte au moins au commencement du XIe siècle."  The De conflictu that is the primary component of the book is limited to a fairly small block of text in the center of the pages; the planctus has been added in the ample margins.  In the illustration below, the planctus is the slightly smaller handwriting surrounding the central blocks.

This version added to our knowledge of the planctus, since it contains 17 verses, or five more than Clermont-Ferrand.  The verses are in a somewhat different order than Clermont-Ferrand, and the text is again not very good.  Lair theorized that some of the "new" verses in Florence Libri are fragments of multiple verses that have collapsed, and that there were perhaps originally 20 verses.  But even with the new verses and some alternate readings, the planctus remains a very problematical text, as demonstrated by several attempts to establish a "true" edition.

The editions

“Complainte sur l’assassinat de Guillaume Longue-épée, duc de Normandie,” edited by Jules Lair, Bibliothèque de l’École des chartes 31 (1870): 389-406.  This edition was based only on Clermont-Ferrand, and was superseded by Lair's second edition below; thus it is not used in these pages.

Jules Lair, Étude sur la vie et la mort de Guillaume Longue-épée, duc de Normandie (Paris: Picard, 1893), 61-70.  Cited in these pages as Lair, it contains a revised edition taking Florence Libri into account.  This book also contains very good facsimiles of both manuscripts, from which the scans on these pages were taken.  I was pleasantly surprised to find that, due to a happy quirk of the electrons, the scans were actually clearer and more brown colorful than the plates in the Étude.  Most of Lair's study is interesting only in historiographical terms; he is far too trusting of Dudo for his discussions of William's career to hold much weight.  But by presenting facsimiles, transcriptions, and an edition of the planctus all under one cover, he provided an invaluable service to scholarship; it is the relative inaccessibility of this book (at least on these shores) that has inspired me to create this web site as a latter-day successor to Lair.

Wilhelm Meyer, Gesammelte Abhandlungen zur mittellateinischen Rythmik (Berlin: Weidmannsche Buchhandlung, 1905), 1:218-219. This is not a true edition, but rather a series of emendations to Lair's second edition.  I have recreated Meyer's version only for those verses in which he has a unique reading.  The entire text of his discussion (which is primarily a metrical analysis) can be found here.

“Complainte sur la mort de Guillaume Longue-épée,” in Philippe Lauer, Le règne de Louis IV, Bibliothèque de l’École des hautes études 127 (Paris: Émile Bouillon, 1900), 319-23.  Cited in these pages as Lauer.  Here, the planctus is one of the pièces justificatives, and is accompanied (at pp. 276-83) by an appendix on the death of William.  This appendix, however, does not treat the event itself as much as give a useful (if brief) overview of subsequent historiography, from Flodoard through William of Malmesbury and beyond.

“Der planctus auf den Normannenherzog Wilhelm Langschwert (942),” editor Phillipp August Becker, Zeitschrift für französische Sprache und Literatur 63 (1939): 190-97.  Cited in these pages as Becker.  Contains a very brief historical introduction, an edition of the text, and a translation into German, with a few end notes on the text.

The translations

“Der planctus auf den Normannenherzog Wilhelm Langschwert (942),” editor Phillipp August Becker, Zeitschrift für französische Sprache und Literatur 63 (1939): 190-97.  Translation into German prose of the entire Planctus. Cited in these pages as Becker.

“Sørgekvadet i Anledning af Vilhelm I' Død,” translated by Erling Albrectsen, in Flodoards annaler (Odense: Odense Universitetsforlag, 1987), 124-38. Contains the Latin text of Lauer alongside a translation into Danish. Cited in these pages as Albrectsen.

Felice Lifshitz, The Norman Conquest of Pious Neustria: Historiographic Discourse and Saintly Relics, 684–1090, Studies and Texts 122 (Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies, 1995), 174. Contains translations into English of verses 2 and 3. Cited in these pages as Lifshitz.

“The Plaintsong of William Longsword,” in The Normans in Europe, edited by Elisabeth M. C. van Houts (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2000), 41.  Cited in these pages as Van Houts.  Contains translations into English of verses 2, 3, 15, 16, and 17.

And a new translation for these pages by Robert Helmerichs, cited as Helmerichs.

Description of the pages in this site

One page contains links to commentaries on the Planctus by various scholars, and other materials relating to it, including a bibliography. Two pages contain transcriptions of both manuscripts, taken from Lair but modified slightly after consultation with the plates. Each individual verse page contains one verse of the Planctus, with scans from the manuscripts, transcriptions of the manuscripts, and the text of the three main editions. 

The order of the verses is that of the editions, all of which agree; the manuscripts have different orders from each other and from the editions.  Each section is headed by the rubric for the source and the verse number in that source (the manuscripts are not divided into verses, but the numbers refer to the order in which they appear in the text).  This is followed by Becker's German translation and my own English translation, with Van Houts’ translation of five of the verses and Lifshitz’ for two.  Finally, where commentary on the text of a verse exists in Lair or Becker, it appears at the end of each page.

This 13th-century bust is, according to tradition, that of William Longsword. It is found in the Musée de l’Abbaye, logis abbatiale de Jumièges; image scanned from Trésors des abbayes normandes (Rouen: Musée des Antiquités/Caen: Musée des Beaux-Arts, 1979), p. 178, no. 218.

Tomb effigy of William Longsword in the cathedral of Rouen, dating to the 14th century. Image from cathedral promotional material.

Possible coin of William Longsword, presently in the Musée des Antiquités de Rouen. †VVILELMVS, †ROTOMAGVS. Click on pictures for larger images. Scanned from Jean Renaud, Les Vikings et la Normandie (Rennes: Ouest-France, 1989), plates between pp. 64-65.


Thanks to Christopher Crocket, who pointed out some typos; Ryan Patrick Crisp, who helped me work through the translation of the especially difficult Verse 12; and Emily Albu, who tried to impose some grace on my translations of several verses. Thanks also to Anders Leegaard Knudsen, who directed my attention to the Albrectsen translation.

Download this site

This link will enable you to download all the files on this site for use on your home computer. Simply create a new directory, left-click on the link, and choose “Save target as” (Explorer) or “Save link as” (Navigator). Save the file in your Planctus directory, and use your favorite un-zipping sofware to un-zip it. (If you don’t have any un-zipping software, try Tucows; search for pkzip and scroll down the screen; you’ll find some free stuff.) Then, point your browser to Index.html in your Planctus directory, bookmark it, and you’re set! If the site is updated, you may want to download the new versions.
Planctus version 1.4


Site history May 1999  Established at Jul 1999  Moved to Carrie Oct 1999  Added translations Apr 2000  Added graphical buttons and mastheads Oct 2000  Designated Haskins Society Approved Site May 2001  Added domain; implemented CSS; added Longsword images; added Sources pageJune 2001 Added Albrectsen translations; added photos of Lair and Clermont to main page; added low-bandwidth edition April 2002  Recoded so all pages will display properly in Netscape

Gaggers Slutty & Maverick Swift & Stars Door Next & Siffredi Rocco & Hotel Celeb & Mobile Porno Fetish Foot & Mobile Bang Milfs & Tokyo Tits Big & Flashers Japanese & Bow Taylor & Box Tranny & Angels Teen Anal & Stars Porn Film Devil's & Gf Ex Mature & Media High Mile & Sluts White Cocks Black & Cock Of Monsters & Cock Her Swith Play She & Blow and Pee & Puuko & Tube 30 Over Men & XXX Asian Gay & Fest Facial & Mobile Gf Ex Milf & Legs Adorable & Mobile Bangers Amateur & Frenzy Throat Deep & Spanish WANKZ & Sex Girl Geek & Hardcore Hood & Solos New & Table Milking & XXX Fetish Gay & Milf Room Back & Sexualz Trans & O'Toole Samuel & Hookers Tranny & Auditions Fresh & Stars Porn Sex Daring & Video Fuck Anal & Mobile Sex Cocks Big & Hogs Cum & Boy for Boy & Sisters Lane & Mobile Holiday Wild MILFs & Sistas Chubby & Overload Pie Cream & Banging Raw & Video Home Porn Young & Fuck Clinic & Sexton Sara & Midget A Bang & Mobile Sex Pussies Hairy & Internal Schoolgirl & Kissing Teens Hot & Wood Le & Teens Seduce Couples & Mobile Girls Lesbian Bad & Models Pornstar Video Sweetheart & Site Super Male & Joy Interracial & Anal Film Devil's & Fever Busty & Bangers Food & Agent Fake & Stars Porn Digital Fame & XXX Ebony Gay & Mobile Videos Sex Hairy & Hell Fetish & Lucas Dylan & Grandma Bangs Grandpa & Bang Tokyo & Invasion Public & HD Girls Nubile & Asia City Sex & Scam Exam Boob & Lez Play Lets & Movies Fat n Old & Suckers Team Double & Smokers Glamour & Angels Anal & Haley Hot & Babes Stockings & Dutch VR Wankz & Matrix Adult & GF Dirty My & Bed The Sharing Girlsway & Vids Allure & Holes 2 Plug & Mobile Girls Tits Small & Granny Nude Hot & Tube Lucas Dylan & Guys Pornication & Ballz Black & Casting Models Young & Date Anal First & Joy Ebony & Grandmas Lusty & Toe Camel Mr & Cocks Big Muscles Big & Dicks Big Extra & Men Performance High & Five Team Fuck & Wood Le Angel Evil & Videos Sex BBW & Videos Groupsex Gay & Mouthfuls Big & Mina XXX & Mobile Fuck Clinic & Mobile Ultra Granny & Bangs Gang Messy & Orgasms Wow & Tube Studios Falcon & Glasses PV & Anal Try Girls & Digital Fame & Pass Off Jerk & Mobile Gf Ex Mature & Cams High Mile & Insertions Taboo & Chicks Video & Mobile Interracial Sinful & Sweeties Nylon & Ground Play TS & Olson Bree & Exposed CFNM & Mobile Facials n Cumshots & 18 Defiled & Matures Hardcore & Victims Land Gang & Service Strapon & Mobile Videos Sex Stocking & Mobile Station Video Porn & Videos Sex Stocking & Doctor Dirty & Tour Fuck Africa & Girls Teen Solo & Teen Film Devil's & Tapes Porno Home & Wyler Mason & Plus 60 Sexy & Sluts Mature Kinky & Butt Her Drill & WANKZ & Dome Gay & BaitBus Mobile & Patrol Blow & Mina Smoking & Web Cyberfolds & Parties Sex Orgy & Hub Fake & Interracial Lethal & Chat Door Next & Mobile Bisexual Extreme & Fires Ashley & Tales Thief Horny & Locker PV & Videos Sex Gay Interracial & Girls Analyzed & Sex Cock Big & Body Teen & Creampie Fat Big & Stars Porn Media High Mile & Penis Circus & Stars Porn Angel Evil & Money Needs Mommy & Lovers Teeny & Pet Teachers Shy & Eve and Adam Nasty & XXX Angie & Fisting Me Teach & Cash For Teens & Films Art Low & Studs Shelf Top & Hell Anal & Three of Party & Sex Lesbian Just & Thrills Fuck Anal & Calogera Cassandra & Russian VR Wankz & XXX Girls Large & Jp Sex Office & Teens Fuck Grandpas & Fatties Hardcore & Sex Cocks Big & Solos Gay & Max Titty & German WANKZ & Bang Gang All & Gfs Ex Blonde & Sextury 21 & Mobile Fatties Hardcore & Seekers Video & Virgins Spoiled & Seeker Milf & Anal Amazing & n Tail Whale & Resort Sex Gay & Mobile Movies Fat n Old & Young Goes Old & Members VIP & Movies Pregnant XXX & World Mega Teen & Hub Sexy & Boys Jerk Circle & Wilde Austin & Mistress Mighty & Coach Dirty & Sites Reality Discount & Rampage Latina & Sluts Fab & Direct Cam My & Sluts Choking Cock & Vids Home Dirty & HD Pissing & Gonzo Lesbian & Switch Wife & Plays Butt & Balls Got Baby & Films Home Stolen & Bunnies do Mommies & Fest Sex Interracial & Ashley About All & Mobile World Movie Shemale & Hardcore Lolly & Tgirls Devil's & Sex Teen Casual & Sitters Baby Frisky & Idol Shemale & Ass My Ate Daughter Step My & Club Pussy 18 & Salad My Tossed Mom Your & Taxi Fake & Ranger Street & Lessons Milf & Mobile Elite Pornstar & Uncovered India & Mobile Videos Sex Gay Interracial & Squad Bang Gang & Gays Groupsex & House Star Porn & Mobile Gfs Ex Blonde & Crazy Get Girls & Mobile Pink the Love & Bitch Me Suck & Agent Public & Auditions Video Rap & Pawg & Teens Toy Sex & Fat n Old & Angels Nasty & Way Natural Teens & DVD Silverstone & MILFs Soccer & Bus Bait & Sandy Club & Guys Rookie & Sex Daring & Sex Cock Big Gay & Interracial Porn Gay & Sins Sex Gay & Sluts Diaper & Japanese Pass Lethal & Mobile Queens Porn Indian & XXX Fucker Mother & Talents New Need We & North Peter & Tube Buddies Door Next & Mobile Porn Cocks Big & Porn Hard & Mobile Frenzy Groupsex & Ultra Milfs & Beavers Hirsute & Auditions Blowjob Real & Video on Caught They & XXX Orgy Gay & Mobile BDSM of Hell & Zoliboy & Pass Reality Gay All & Steele Lexington & All On & Mobile Babes Black Bad & Sextreme 21 & Porno Pom Pom & Club Sex Cougar & Ass My Clean & Mouth Teen Ass & BGG First & Toons Fucking & Rhodes Sammie Pure & Andi Inked & Shavers Jp & Hellcat Little & Babes Banged Gang & Girls School J & Spanking Sinful & Brazil from Tranny & Hitchhiker Gay & Acrobats Anal & Parties Sex Young Mobile & Belle Brandi & Queens Race My & Briar Brookelynne & Party Boyz & Bangs Gang Road & Mobile Parties Teen Wild & Studios Pride & Mobile Thrills Sex Asian & Mobile Hardcore Gays Black & Swedish VR Wankz & Kelly Dream & Way Girls & Video Teen Private & Casting Door Next & Erotica Lesbo & Moan Teen Make & Girls Tits Small & XXX Bear Gay & Mobile Sex Ebony Just & Gloryholes Cock Huge & Lesbians Teen Virgin & Pops Panty & Mobile Spanking Sinful & Gag Them Make & VR Wankz & Teacher Jp & Bus Bang & Lickers Ass Nasty & Anal Young Old & Gape N Gag & Tube Buddies Door Next & Bitches BioHazard & Babysitter The Bang Couples & Club Milf Hot & Mobile Porno Toys Sex & Bangers Housewife & XXX Amateur Gay & Porno Bears Gay & Mobile Porno Pussy Hairy & Feeds Private & Parade Ass & Dicks Big Like Tits Big & Training Whore Piss & Young Web & Mobile World Mega Teen TMW & Parodies Film Devil's & XXX Interracial Gay & Mobile House Sex Interracial & Mamas Sugar & Sex Anal First Her & 30 Over Men & House Sex Interracial & Nobili Kathia With Sex & Mobile Ultra Milfs & Parlor Massage & Network Bros Bang & Elite Pornstar & Live Nuru & Wife My For Cocks New & Squirters Slutty & Voracious Angel Evil & Pov Spy & Tits Natural Big Christoph's & Sex Teen Project & Dirty Pretty & Bay Porn Home & Bushy Bushy & Portugese VR Wankz & Girls Lesbian Bad & Raw Door Next & Mobile Heat Latinas & Search Stud Porn & Lust Toys Sex & XXX Lust Sun & Files Squirting & Throat Dual & Hub Sexy & Trannys Taboo & Cam Spy Break Spring & Studies Fuck & Studs Star All & Parade Asian & Babes Black Bad & Pass Lethal & Feet Magical & Invasion Brutal & Guys Live Real & Movies Sex Tits Big & Network Movies Sex & Swingers Rookie & Lesbians Us Made She & Cash for Shemales & Huge Shes & Video Sweetheart & Angel Joanna & Gals Voyeur & Cash for Swallow & Porno Fetish Foot & Cocks Black Box White & GF Your Trick & Lactalia & Adventure Ass Big & Fucked and Pregnant & Mobile Sex Breasts Big & Tour Fuck African & Poles Big Holes Tight & Mouths Drilled & Movs At & Throated & Valley Anal & Angels X & Trouble Tranny & Titties Club & Chix Young Dicks Old & Tapes Camera Hidden & Gasm Cry & film on Fatties & HD Sex Bi & House Hot & Mobile Matures Hardcore & Asians See & Blacks Try Teens & Quickies Oral & Portal Lesbians Young & Banged and Young & Pass XXX My & Mobile Videos Sex Woman Older & Sydney Solo & Taxi Fake Female & Rotica X Mature & Sex Mature Sinful & Massage Bubbly & Love Lesbian Young Old & Creampies O & Mobile Videos Sex BBW & Sweeties Creampied & Hub Fake & Saint Silvia & Porn Reality Star All & Swedish WANKZ & Mobile Lesbian Sinful & Suckers Teen Little & Mobile Thrills Fuck Anal & Pink Katie & Boys Oh & Sex Handicap Raw & Sex First 18 & Pass Visual Pink & Mobile Interracial Porn Gay & Teens I & Tube Twink Door Next & Kissing Teens Real & Videos Mom Step & 2 Season Voracious Angel Evil & Mobile Hardcore Gay Teen & Lesbo Lipstick & Latinas Working & Mobile Hunter BBW & Six Got She & UK Agent Fake & Tube Central Fisting & Interracial All & Of Best Very The & Pass Sites Porn All & Mobile Gays Black Raw & Lovers Sex Latin & Mobile Tits Big Fresh & Fu Kunt & Passions Moms & Teacher Old Tricky & CosPlay J & Casting Anal Teen & Interracial Sinful & 18 Exploited & Blowjobs POV & Anal Gone Milfs & Live Fame X & xxx Mom & Women Mature & Box Pink Juicy & This POV & Nerdy is She & Know Didn't They & Butts Juicy Round & XXX Facials Gay & DP First Her & Hardcore Bears Gay & Mobile Videos Bisexual Hot & Thrills Shemale & Tube Cummings Cody & GF Your Sell & Trick Lesbo & Dildoes Japanese & Mobile Movies Sex Tits Big & Flesh 18 & Abused Door Next Girls & Sex Gay First His & Honeys Ball & Trannys Filled Cum & Junkies Cock Monster & Digital House Dog & Slurp Japanese & Angel Evil & Mobile Legs Adorable & Cream Got Girls & Polish WANKZ & Teens Fresh & Male Feeds Private & Hos Toe Camel & Whores Teenage & Mobile Babes Stockings & Tube Maskurbate & X Casting Private & Tube House Hot & Interracial Explicit & Adventures Busty & Bang Fist & Eighteen Am I & 69 Idols & Mobile Queens Tit Big & Queens Porn Indian & Mobile Mature Fuck & Bunnies Brown & 4K Beauty & Lingies & Productions Quebec & Tube Men Performance High & Heat Latinas & HD Dreams & Live Angel Blue & Nippon Anal & Orgies Want Teens & X Erotica & Haze Allie & Mobile Porno BBW Ebony & Tube Dicks Big Extra & Pass Japanese All & Angels Beauty & Offer BASE Christmas OFF Monthly AllJapanesePas & Wives Whore Cheating & Girls Grande & Gay Sinful & Cash For Twinks & Gfs Ex Bad & Scarlett Suicide & Mobile Planet Movie Lesbian & Sex Ebony Just & Now Bukkake & Mobile House Star Porn & Back Bare Digital Male & Land Teen Lovely & Stallion Raging & Bush Super & rooms Massage & Facials Backroom & Twink Door Next & Hardcore Cheerleaders & Alysa Queen Anal & Chunkers Lesbian & Bangers Amateur & Lesbian Sinful & Galore Cuties & Tokyo 18 & Cams Home & Sluts Cigarette & Hardcore Bisexuals & Ninjas Job Blow & Mobile Club Gay Teen & Kristi Pregnant & Search MILF & Videos Bisexual Hot & Casting XXX & Dani Ditzi & Tube Reality Male & Dose Sex Daily & JP POV & Lesbian Real a by Seduced & Girls Newbie & Pass Ox & Sex Group X & Robots Fucking & Parties Wild College & Gulpers Cum Young & Mobile Gays Groupsex & Live Angel Burning & Angels Creampie & Studios Jocks & Mobile Fever Facials & Queens Tit Big & Club Fight Nude & Lesbians Tokyo & Pass Porn HD & Porno Toys Sex & Dancers Male Nude World Door Next & Girls Leroy's & XXX Mature Gay & Minnie Girl Cam & Brothas Cock Insane & Transsensual & Lesbea & Pie Cream Tit Big & Fisting Tranny Raw & Mobile Handjobs Sinful & Italian WANKZ & MILF Film Devil's & Gape Teen Make & Embrianna & Girls Daddys Dirty & Bang Monster Stallion Raging & Tube Hookups Door Next & Cougars Sexy & Sexxxy Love & Teens Seeking Couples & Facials Fresh & Bang Pregnant & Teen Latina My & Checkup Anal & Cocks Shocking & Jones Dane & XXX Darkko Jonni & Lesbians Tape Sex & Mobile Hardcore Cheerleaders & Uncensored Biohazard & Male Door Next & Mobile Libertines Young & Slut Wife My Do & Pros Tranny & Sinner Sweet & Teens Try & Squirters League Big & Hookups Door Next & Me and Mommy My Fuck & Blowjobs Teen Only & Live Immoral & Coeds Black My & Kittens Crave Cougars & Mobile Hardcore Hood & Sensual X & Triplets Visconti & Facials Just & Videos Sex Woman Older & Live Angel Evil & XXX Men Muscle & Ass Teen My Bang & Matures Cumming & Angel Burning & Italian Pass Lethal & Porno BBW Ebony & Peak DVD & Teens Innocent So Not & Agent Female & Sex Latina & 18 Lethal & Porno Transsexuals & Mobile Fat n Old & Mobile Ultra Lesbians & Ghetto White & Pass Download & Studs and Girls & Fucks Simple & Fucked Grannies & Hub Fake & 18 Love Boys & Girl For Girl & Mobile Babes Banged Gang & Mobile Videos Groupsex Gay & Gangbang Film Devil's & Parties Teen Wild & Club Boobie & Smuts Tranny & Japan Wierd & Younger Older Lesbian & Queens Job Tug & Cocks Super Gay & Gals Enslaved & Gf Ex Tits Big & Chicks In Dicks Tranny & Mobile Teens Gay Sinful & Lee Devon & Mobile Porno Bears Gay & Cop Fake & Porn 2 Born & Sex Virgin 18 & Man Butt & Babes Amour & Tube Digital Male & Swappers Cum Tranny & Passions Golden & Tube Male Door Next & Gays Latin Hard & Youth Hardcore & Virgin Squirting & Elders Easy & Undies Hairy & Dream Montreal & Star Charmane & Mobile Gays Latin Hard & Mobile Queens Lingerie & HD Sex Twink & Ultra Gay & Studios Falcon & Chunkers For Cash & Porn Builder Body Hot & Handjobs Sinful & Movies XXX Raw & XXX Bangers Boat Bang & Girls Teen & Mobile HD Sex Bi & Oasis Shot Cum & Fanatics DP & Sistas Pregnant & Sistas Lesbian & Mobile Video Fuck Anal & French Pass Lethal & Kinky is Mandy & Mouth 2 Ass Dirty & Chix Cheer & Mobile HD Sex Twink & Penetrations Mega & Babes Flashy & Mobile Porno Transsexuals & Massage Soapy & Mania Sex Teen & Adventure Anal Moms & Tube Tryouts Anal Young & City Sex Lesbian & Porn Voyeur Live & Mobile Movies XXX Raw & Videos Movies Massage Fantasy & Taxi Fake Female & Mobile Banging Raw & Tease Asian & Honeys Young Wild & Beauty Anal & Enema Milk & X Hard & Before That Done Never & Gape Me Show & German VR Wankz & Mobile Queens Sex Asian & Banged Gang Tranny & Agent Tricky & Angels Gaping & Hub Fake & Sweeties Creampied & Italian VR Wankz & Taxi Fake Female & Zine Core Teen & Shemales Latin & Hub Sexy & Sex Breasts Big & Zone Sex Shemale & House Tranny & Swallows Time First & Dudes Muscle Hot & Glasses Covered Cum & Anal Try Teens & Milf Time Summer & Mobile Bears Gay Raw & Mobile Sex Panty Sinful & Creampie Curry & Pass Spectrum Male & Flix Dirty & Hunter Tits Small & Vids Absolute & Hilton Hanna & Sites World Door Next & Cummings Cody & 18 Seductive & Amateurs Crazy Cock & Latina Cute & Art Foot 21 & Leigh Sabina & Skow B & Hunter Man & Stars Porn Massage Fantasy & Courtesans Young & Mobile Gf Ex Teen Sexy & Tube Twink Door Next & Chicks Bus School & Mobile Film on Fatties & Amore Amanda & Portuguese WANKZ & Gf Ex Milf & Japanese VR Wankz & Galore Boobs Huge & Stepmom My Bang & Boring No & Life Open & Girlfriend Ex Revenge & Nymphs Little Naughty & Erotica Sport & Tits Big Fresh & Mobile Studio Sex Latina & Junkies Reality & Leone Sunny & Ryder Dylan & Leslie John & Mobile Porn Teen Fresh & Porn Go Teens & com Tranny & Mobile Movies Pornstar Raw & Adriano Mike & Boobs Mini & Teens Campus Hot & Teens Cumaholic & Vids Teen Home & Mobile Hardcore HD & Pussy Hairy My Fuck & Angels Euro & Mobile Pass Japanese All & Fever Hole Ass & Video Teen I & Sites Bonus Massage Fantasy & Parties Sex Young & Factor Lesbian & Club Gay Teen & Creampies Lethal & Darlings and Daddies & Worldwide BangBros & Teens Tranny Real & Mobile Groupsex X & Friction Hard Stallion Raging & Gays Black Raw & Bbw Sinful & XXX Videos Gay & Mobile Lovers Sex Latin & German Pass Lethal & Bangs Gang Devil's & XXX Teens Euro & Holiday Wild Milfs & Mobile Cocks Big Muscles Big & Cuckold Him Make & Porno Ass Ebony & Movies Pornstar Raw & Fuckers Foot Bare & Gina Teen & Mobile Babes Blowjobs & Toons Hardcore & Mobile Sex Lesbian Just & Massage Girl All & Girls Solo & Tube Buddies Door Next & Queens Lingerie & Whores Service & Seducers Tranny & Mobile Thrills Shemale & Sex Guy Cable & Reality Male & Teacher Teen & Club Core Teen & Central Fisting & James St Addison & Dick That Stroke & Panty Teen Wet & Chix India & Cock Huge First His & Claire St Minnie & Soup Milf & 18 Teens Tiny & Oasis Teen My & Hardcore Gay Teen & Bitch It Jerk & Station Video Porn & Hardcore Gays Black & Shemale Film Devil's & Best Blows Mommy & Box Gf Ex & Mind Erotic & Bangers Preggo & Mobile Hardcore Bisexuals & Boss MILF My & Attackers Strap & Trannys Tempting & Love Girls About & Sonia Lady & World Sex Real & Spermantino & Mobile HD Sex Shemale & Hardcore HD & Reality Creampie & Videos Sex Hairy & Man My Strap-On I & Undercover Brother & Hospital Fake & Orgies Teen Drunken & Gonzo 18 Over Just & Mobile Pass Sites Porn All & Gonzo Ass & Wife My Banged Tranny & Sex Pussies Hairy & Bull Trystan & Nurse Jp & Bisexual Extreme & Chicks Squirting & Frenzy Groupsex & Tryouts PornStar & Mobile Movies Pregnant XXX & Babes Footsie & Mobile Amateurs Crazy Cock & Hunter BBW & Orgies Squirting & Planet Movie Lesbian & Grades for Sex & Sex Hair Red & Erotica Foot & Mobile Siffredi Rocco & Tour Sex My & Virgins Shabby & Peak DVD Men & Factory Teen & Bangs Gang Amazing & Girls Hairy All & Hospital in Horny & Mobile Porno Ass Ebony & Pals Anal & Pass Heatwave & fuck to love Teens & Games Visual Pink & Nati Naughty & Redheads Love We & Day A 4 Pimp & Pass Black & Cocktail Sumption Cum & Desire 4K & Babes Full Booty & Wood My Wank & Finally Her Fucked I & Sites all for Pass 1 & Pie Amateur & Knights Ebony & Jp Outdoor & Octane High Stallion Raging & Mobile Porn Voyeur Live & Facials 1000 & Girls JSchool & Video and Pix & Studio Booty & Galore Butts Bubble & Swallowers Born Natural & Mobile Panty Teen Wet & Patrick Tera & Queens Sex Asian & Ebony Door Next & Throats Young & Nadia Nude & Fuckers Scary & Boobs Real Huge & Babysitter Dirty & Lesbians Lucky & Max CFNM & Spanish Pass Lethal & Harry Handjob & Mobile Fuck to Love Teens & Pass Porn Midget & Online Clark Christoph & Massage Nuru & Empire Ocean Aletta & Spa Tricky & Mobile Fucked and Pregnant & Land Gape & French VR Wankz & xxx Girlfriends & Sex Lesbian First Her & Drillers Teen & Mobile Fuckers Foot Bare & Maskurbate & Cocks Black Teens White & Mobile Sex Teen Project & Solos Busty & Teens Teamed Double & Pass Sites Gay All & Teens Gay Sinful & Polish Pass Lethal & Malone Jake & Mature Fuck & Jobs Tug & X Brutal & Wagner Paul Stars Door Next & Orgy Perfect & Mobile Zone Sex Shemale & Hardcore Gay Just & Access Movie Gay & Fever Facials & Massage Fantasy & Spanish VR Wankz & Hub Sexy & Whitey Banging & Mag Facial & Ass Sexy Phat & Party Home Drunk & Girls Hair Brown & Action in Bums & Addiction Ebony & Juggs Juicy Big & Mobile Petite Sexy & Porno Pussy Hairy & Films Girlfriends & XXX D Tommy & Japanese WANKZ & Exposed MILFs & Brooks Abbey & Challenge Sucking Cock & Libertines Young & 18 BangBros & HeShe Club & Auditions Tranny & Bangbros Mobile & Pass Movie Pride & Wendy Want & Stars Porn Do & Pink The Love & Ass My Teach & Facial First His & Gf Ex Teen Sexy & Boyz Hairy Stallion Raging & Cheeks Ebony & Sluts Intermixed & Dungeon Inferno Club & Girl Mommy's & Polish VR Wankz & French WANKZ & Pimped Got She & Hunter Squirt & Cocks Gay Giant & Mobile BBW Sinful & Internal Ebony & Sluts Eye Pink & Time Party College & Work at XXX & Matures Japanese & Glasses Fucking & Cravings Foot & Access Shemale & Mobile Sex Mature Sinful & X Dark & Masseur Tricky & X Nylons & Real 4 Squirt & Mobile Fucked Grannies & Rivers Evan & Shemales Black Love I & Wild Going Teenagers & World Door Next & Babes Blowjobs & Sticks on Milfs & Heart Jenny & Ghetto Granny & Analyzed Teens & Toys Fuck Wild & Porn Cocks Big & Street Booty Feet Black & Mobile Network Movies Sex & Bears Gay Raw & Milfs Jp & Hardcore Vidal Nacho & Mobile Gay Sinful & Trannys Glazed & 69 Cartoon & Uncovered EXGF & Thrills Sex Asian & Mobile Hardcore Bears Gay & Virgins Cock & Force Fetish Central Fisting & Mobile Pass Sites Gay All & XXX Sin Jay & HD Sex Shemale & Teens Me Give & Admissions Gloryhole & Fetishes Secret & Tube Dungeon Inferno Club & Ultra Granny & Mobile Gf Ex BBW Sexy & Tube Ebony Door Next & Tube Boys Jerk Circle & Swallows Only & Trick Escort & Swedish Pass Lethal & Mobile Sins Sex Gay & Mobile Girlfriend Ex Revenge & White Em Like I & Bdsm Of Hell & Bang Milfs & Loops Gay Vintage & 3D Films Porn & Duty Active & Solos 360 & Bang Solo & World Movie Shemale & Asses Round Tits Big & Trip Road Transsexual & Family the of Out & Digital Male & Sandwich Tranny & Buddies Door Next & Some 3 Teens & Spencer Harley & Ever Milfs Hottest & Throat Filled Cum & Parties Sex College Gay & Access Movie & Young N Old & Mobile Wife my for Cocks New & Tube House Hot & Girls Dominated & Squirtalicious & Orgy Oriental & Plays Speculum & Mojo Marcus & Facials n Cumshots & Male Icon & Bitch That Disgrace & Porn Teen Fresh & Mobile Interracial Explicit & Digital Sex Bi & Pass Bang & Score He Can & Movs Sex Teen & Studio Sex Latina & Naturals 21 & Moone Sophie Sweet & Petite Sexy & Movies Slut & Lovers Teeny Mobile & Junkies Bang Gang & Cock Big First Her & Pussy Teen Bang & Daily Rod & Only Stars Teen & Film Devil's & Bangers Seat Back & Ultra Lesbians & Twink Super & Tube Dicks Big Extra & Mobile Gf Ex Tits Big & Club Lesbian Granny & Russian WANKZ & Gf Ex BBW Sexy & Teens Toy Home & Mobile Ass Sexy Phat & Fuckers Tittie & Sex Date Blind Gay & Fucked Me Watch & Mobile Hardcore Gay Just & Games Spectrum Male & Cougars Lethal & Babes Legal Just & Anal 1st Her & Brazil In Life My & Russian Pass Lethal & Girl My Shoot I & XXX Military Gay & X Massage & Cuties Lez & Pornication & XXX Hentai Gay & Ferrara Manuel & Sex Panty Sinful & Anal Erotic 21 & Tryouts Anal Young & Orgy Gay First & Mobile World Sex Real & Blacks Love Teens & Creampies Titty & Silvera Joey & Portuguese Pass Lethal &